Skip to main content
ZCF

Home of cricket conversation, community and memory

Discussion

Is the top order becoming settled?

Zimbabwe Cricket Forum 18 posts 27 views

Discussion

ZCF Hall of Famer

Opening post

For limited overs:

1. Sibanda

2. Masakadza

3. Taylor

For Tests:

1. Mawoyo

2. Sibanda

3. Masakadza

4. Taylor

They seem like combinations that all things being equal, could serve Zimbabwe for many years to come.

On an unrelated note, what is your first eleven for the ICC World Twenty20? There are a few interesting questions raised from this recently concluded series:
Would you stick with the 5 specialist bowlers?

Is Price able to force his way back in, and at the expense of Cremer or Utseya? Or a return to triple-spin considering it's Sri Lanka?

Does Chigumbura keep his spot? Does he make way for another allrounder or a batsman like Coventry?

Ervine vs Waller vs Taibu - it seems to me that they are all fighting for the one spot

If Taibu players, does Taylor still keep wicket ala 2007?

Who is 12th man?
Veteran

brmtaylor.com admin wrote: Would you stick with the 5 specialist bowlers?


I dont think so I think Ham, Stuart and even Taylor can have a toss. We need another batsmen to take our score to the 180ish in each game instead of trying to defend low totals with our bowlers.


brmtaylor.com admin wrote: Is Price able to force his way back in, and at the expense of Cremer or Utseya? Or a return to triple-spin considering it's Sri Lanka?


No Price in My team, I think Price can have one more ceremonial Game to just say good bye and retire. I think its safe to retire


brmtaylor.com admin wrote: Does Chigumbura keep his spot? Does he make way for another allrounder or a batsman like Coventry?


I feel for Chigs the same way peeps want Coventary in the team. Purely sentimental at the whole talent potential story bit both are out of Form. I would throw in wild card Chibhabha there!


brmtaylor.com admin wrote: Ervine vs Waller vs Taibu - it seems to me that they are all fighting for the one spot


Taibu, without a thought unfortunately.


brmtaylor.com admin wrote: If Taibu players, does Taylor still keep wicket ala 2007?


Would rather have tibba behind the stumps to get up the nerves of the batsmen a bit and just generally chirp!


brmtaylor.com admin wrote: Who is 12th man?


I would also add whether we should chase or we should bat first if we win the toss. I say we chase. Setting the pace is too much pressure in my view. And If peeps like Levi bat first they would also have the same problem. But when the score is set everyone knows what they have to do.

1. Sibanda

2. Masakadza

3. Taylor

4. Tibba

5. Stu

6. Elton

7. Cremer

8. Usteya

9. Muzhange

10. Jarvis

11. Mpofu

12 Waller/Ervine I would put one of these in for Muzhange if we decide to go with 4 bowlers
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer
I can't remember the squad, but this would be my T20 team, considering we're in spin friendly conditions.

1. Sibanda

2. Mazakadza

3. Taylor (wkt/cpt)

4. Waller

5. Coventry

6. Ervine

7. Chigumbura

8. Cremer

9. Utsea

10. Jarvis

11. Mpofu/ Price
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer

sloandog wrote:I can't remember the squad, but this would be my T20 team, considering we're in spin friendly conditions.

1. Sibanda

2. Mazakadza

3. Taylor (wkt/cpt)

4. Waller

5. Coventry

6. Ervine

7. Chigumbura

8. Cremer

9. Utsea

10. Jarvis

11. Mpofu/ Price


I like this team.
My All-time Zimbabwe XI
Neil Johnson, Brendan Taylor, Murray Goodwin, Andy Flower (w), David Houghton, Sean Williams, Heath Streak (c), Andy Blignaut, Paul Strang, Eddo Brandes, Blessing Muzarabani
Veteran
i think if the team wanted another spinner they would be better off picking Waller. That way the team will have an extra batter.
Definately need Coventry for the T/20's. Would give him a lengthy run in the ODi's and see if he can bat his way into form.
Legend
No Pricey for me any more in this form of the game.

We need the extra batsman, so a combination of Waller, Chigs, Hammy, maybe even Taylor or Matsi will have to do. That said, Chigs only merits his place if he's able to contribute an over ot two with the ball.

Tibba behind the stumps for sure. With the bat Tibba is a better version of Matsi (quick between the wickets, even more innovative), so I'd have him take Matsi's spot. Which leaves two batting spots for three contestants: Matsi, Waller, Ervine -- at the moment Waller's bowling looks a strong argument in his favour. Haven't seen Matsi bowl recently.

Unfortunately Coventry has no further opportunities to claim a place. Would have liked to see him in the mix.

my XI (batting order from 4 downwards flexible according to the match situation)

Vusi

Hammy

Taylor

Matsi/Ervine

Tibba

Waller

Chigs (wildcard: Coventry)

Cremer

Pro

Jarvis/Muzhange

Mpofu
Taylor makes Foster Mutizwa look like MS Dhoni with the gloves so we can't allow him to keep wicket in Sri Lanka.

He conceded a lot of byes and 'missed' clear catches. BT isn't athletic enough anymore to squat behind the stumps. Taibu will keep!
My team for World T20:-

1. Sibanda

2. Masakadza

3. Taylor(c)

4. Taibu (w/k)

5. Coventry

6. Waller

7. Chigumbura

8. Cremer

9. Price

10. Jarvis

11. Mpofu
Veteran

samedwards wrote:My team for World T20:-

1. Sibanda

2. Masakadza

3. Taylor(c)

4. Taibu (w/k)

5. Coventry

6. Waller

7. Chigumbura

8. Cremer

9. Price

10. Jarvis

11. Mpofu


I would pick this team too. Price has the experience to guide this team in pressure situations, many times our team has capitulated or gave up defending a low total and I think Price's willingness to fight fight all the way will be needed. Mpofu is now the wise hand, Jarvis is settling in nicely and I like Cremer and Chigs in there. Chigs once won a county contract, there is still something in there, he needs to drag it out. I like Cremer given that it'll be SL, he is a future world star and can bat but he is not cemented in there yet for me; Vitori, Muzhange or Masakadza Jnr can still get his place if they find something on those pitches or if Chigs doesn't fire bowling wise. I have faith in Waller, he is a class act (Ervine has a lot to do to steer him out of the way). I have to persist with Coventry, if two of either Vusi, Hammi or Taylor get out cheaply (very conceivable) we need a guy to smack the ball and get the run rate to a respectable level before Waller & Co consolidate. The top 4 picks itself.
Veteran
What i dont understand is
why everone keeps singing this Coventry song when the guy has been clearly out of form even on the domestic scene. Lets leave Muzhange in and Cremer looks like he derserves a spot judging from his last perfomamce in the tri series aganist SA AND BD, may be we could play around with Waller and chigs.Our batting tends to faulter alot underpressure so lets leave Mastikenyeri in. So a good team would be Vusi sibanda,HAMILTON MASAKADZA,TAYLOR, MASTI,Taibu,Chigumbura ,Waller/Jarvis,Creamer,chris mpofu,Richard muzhange
Veteran

zimlover wrote:What i dont understand is why everone keeps singing this Coventry song when the guy has been clearly out of form even on the domestic scene.


So was Vusi when I remember only me and sloan sang his praises around these parts. Sometimes if there's enough talent in there (enough to improve the current lineup if realised), we have to stick our necks out and risk it. Vusi was worth it and so is Coventry in the short formats.
Veteran

Boundary wrote:So was Vusi when I remember only me and sloan sang his praises around these parts. Sometimes if there's enough talent in there (enough to improve the current lineup if realised), we have to stick our necks out and risk it. Vusi was worth it and so is Coventry in the short formats.


Vusi Debuted before the Rebel era then he was axed and worked his way back in again, then he lost form and was axed then he hit the First class with 1000 runs in a season and captained the A team as well and he was an automatic pic. Coventary as much as I like to see him in the team, HAS to dominate our weak bowlers in the domestic else we are not even doing him any favours by chucking him in the deepend AGAIN!
ZCF Hall of Famer
most people only want coventry here in the T20

Thats fine.... he provdes muscle

its like a rugby league/union team who is pretty good but getting a bity overawed in the forward pack...sometimes you have to put in a big bopper in there who isnt as talented to beef up the drive... (the cricketing equivalent is run rate).
Veteran
it would seem th ship has sailed for Coventry. unless if he does a Vusi ( i.e perform in the domestic game).
ZCF Hall of Famer
In this time, with our weapons,

The door is never shut.

Just ask mats i.

He scores a century of 60 balls he's back in
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer
Matsi would never last 60 deliveries, let alone score 100 runs.
My All-time Zimbabwe XI
Neil Johnson, Brendan Taylor, Murray Goodwin, Andy Flower (w), David Houghton, Sean Williams, Heath Streak (c), Andy Blignaut, Paul Strang, Eddo Brandes, Blessing Muzarabani
ZCF OriginalVeteran

eugene wrote:Matsi would never last 60 deliveries, let alone score 100 runs.


😂

He scored 80 off 37 balls last season. http://www.espncricinfo.com/zdod-11/eng ... 30723.html
CremerCurrans

Reply

Login to reply.