sloandog wrote: ↑Tue Sep 17, 2019 4:26 pm
Hhm, Ben Ducket has more talent in his left finger nail than all those names combined! If you’ve never seen him bat live, which you haven’t clearly, don’t make assumptions or camparisons which simply don’t warrant discussion. He’s an unreal batter and would out bat all the guys you mentioned, in ODI cricket or Test Cricket.
sloandog wrote: ↑Tue Sep 17, 2019 4:29 pm
And by the way, while we’re talking of Kazuza, have you ever seen him bat..?
I've seen both of them in the flesh and on TV, at various stages in their careers(never watched Kasuza play red ball cricket live though).
My high regard for Kasuza has never been hidden. It's criminal that he still hasn't played an international for Zimbabwe. In fact, I believe he is the best batsman of those 5 names I listed(he would have had brilliant numbers if he started out and played more in the middle order in the Logan Cup and other formats).
So Ben Duckett IS comparable to those batsmen in my view*. I don't believe he would upstage them in the Logan Cup or within the Zimbabwe Test batting order.
Having said that, none of those batsmen, Duckett included would make the top 84 batsmen list of active South African batsmen.
NB: Not directly related to your posts Sloan, but sometimes I laugh to myself at the number of people on this forum who infer I'm dumb, or either think they are smarter than me in general, or have more experience in and around the game of cricket than I do. Anyho...