Skip to main content
ZCF

Home of cricket conversation, community and memory

Discussion

How competitive is our Logan Cup?

Zimbabwe Cricket Forum 4 posts 26 views

Discussion

Veteran

Opening post

We haven't played a test match in a year, in the meantime Pak have graduated themselves into the big leagues, Aus is recovering but NZ and SL seem catchable. Also, WI could be caught unawares. In other words, we could be mixing with the SL, WI, NZ crowd and with more experience pushing Pak, maybe Aus and India all the way depending on the venue. But we haven't played in a year. What we've been doing is playing FC cricket (which is why I "hate" Zim articles on cricinfo, they inevitably have someone in the comments section mentioning Ireland but Ireland don't have FC). Also in those comment sections, some Aussie was lamenting on player depth, blaming in on the Shield standards of late. In other words, if the matches in the Logan Cup are competitive and force players to improve themselves, we could be a surprise package when we fully emerge from international isolation. I love our domestic season and the knowledgeable debate we all have about, basing mostly on the stats available to us. So my question is, how relevant are those stats as far as international cricket is concerned? If someone made an impact on the South African scene similar to Querl's, they would surely go on to have a good international career, if not a great one. Another thing I've noted: we get a lot of young English pros in our setup now, which can only be a good thing (wkt keeping issue aside) and we surely impacted Compton's (and now Ballance's) career positively. So, really, how good is our standard? The WI tour is based mostly on domestic form, can we trust that form to translate internationally?
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer
It's hard to say isn't it. I think we need to look no further than Mr Keegan Meth. He destroyed, and continues to destroy the batting top order of all the sides in FC cricket, but when it comes to international cricket he seriously struggles due to his lack of pace.

But if we look at guys like Tino Mawoyo who scored 163* against Pakistan in a test match, it came off the back of good domestic form. So it's a tough one ay mate
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer
I think it is improving. Jarvis' performance in NZ is comparable to his LC efforts. Ballance is about 10+ runs better in the LC than the County CC, but then Compton wasn't heaps better in Zim and now he is doing ok for England.
The Third Innings
Legend
Average or fringe county players are not setting the world alight any more on the Logan Cup. Meth may not be not be of international class, but I guess he could hold down a permanent place with most second division county sides like Derbys, Gloucs, Leics, Northants. Of course these sides would themselves get slaughtered on the international stage.

When national team players are around, which is an important factor, the three top sides in the Logan Cup (Tuskers, Rhinos, Goats) should easily match 2nd division county standards and, in home conditions, would probably give most 1st division sides a good game.

Depth in batting is a worrying factor though.

Reply

Login to reply.