Skip to main content
ZCF

Home of cricket conversation, community and memory

Discussion

Zim Selection Policy

Zimbabwe Cricket Forum 6 posts 30 views

Discussion

Veteran

Opening post

Does Zim have a selection policy in place or we are working on a hunch type of policy .

I found something interesting about New Zealand

http://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/cricket/60 ... y-revealed


How would the current New Zealand players rate on the selection pie:

The Equation Factors that make up the pie: Significant performance 35% Consistent performance 25% Fielding 10% Fitness 10% Selectors' intuition 5% Contribution to the team 15%

Jesse Ryder Better than most of his team-mates, but doesn't do himself any favours.

Has lacked consistency and big scores with the bat but would score high on selectors' intuition.

A big fat zero on fitness, middle rating on fielding given his safe hands, but down again on team contribution given the markers are leadership, work ethic and mentoring ability.

Score: 40/100

Tim Southee Bit of a lad, but had a wonderful World Cup and generally stays fit.

Mark up on consistency with the ball, fitness and fielding but down on team contribution given his little slip-ups like the airline antics and general team clown.

Score: 65/100

Chris Martin Interesting case. Looks a spent force, but has a habit of proving his critics wrong.

He does pull out the odd big spell with the ball, but has lean patches. Consistent with the bat - but not in a way the selectors want. Low in the field, but high in fitness and contribution to the team given he is one of the most professional players in the squad.

Score: 50/100

Brendon McCullum Never everyone's cup of tea these days but he is a matchwinner with the bat. Inconsistent in one-dayers but quite the opposite in tests. Fit as a fiddle, keeps and fields well and wants to be leader.

The inside word is he has been very supportive of new skipper Ross Taylor.

Score: 70/100

Kane Williamson Keeps impressing good judges with the simplicity and effectiveness of his batsmanship. Turns starts into big scores and is consistent. Looks fit, fields well, works hard and the selectors think the world of him so scores highly in every category.

Score: 80/100


Lets rate our current Zim team.........
Let us not try to rationalize the past selections because you will end up in the mental asylum.

Whether handing out NCube his test debut , Chakabva ahead of Forster, Chibhabha ahead of Zhuwao, etc the selectors have lost my respect.

The selectors seem to immune to common sense and technical knowledge let alone using an analytical system that can lend objectivity to their mood swings.
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer
Chamu ahead of Cephas was a Bad move iyo?
The Third Innings
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer
I think he meant that either one of Chamu or Cephas being selected was a bad move.
My All-time Zimbabwe XI
Neil Johnson, Brendan Taylor, Murray Goodwin, Andy Flower (w), David Houghton, Sean Williams, Heath Streak (c), Andy Blignaut, Paul Strang, Eddo Brandes, Blessing Muzarabani
I like this... Supports the case for Chatara and Meth in the Test setup. Both have been extremely consistent
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer

eugene wrote:I think he meant that either one of Chamu or Cephas being selected was a bad move.


Well, that would be more understandable.
The Third Innings

Reply

Login to reply.