Skip to main content
ZCF

Home of cricket conversation, community and memory

Discussion

Surely you could have acknowledged that I was completely right?

Zimbabwe Cricket Forum 39 posts 57 views

Discussion

ZCF Hall of Famer

Opening post


1. "What we quickly realised was that hosting Tests is something that costs us a lot of money, and that is a commodity we do not have at the moment" ZC's recently appointed MD Faisal Hasnain told ESPNcricinfo. "As things stand, it costs us money because we get almost negligible amounts from our current TV rights and sponsorships, and these continue till 2019. We will concentrate on playing more ODIs and T20s, home and away, under the ODI league and the T20 open format, which will hopefully enable us to cut expenditure and potentially generate greater revenues."

Any Zimbabwean fan could have told you that Sherlock. Proved just how inadequate and underprepared you were for the role. Imagine a CEO saying this within months of his/her appointment. I told you he’s downright incompetent.


2. source the ICC Test fund no longer exists



3. … to play Tests at home … we just would not be able to sustain it financially, unless we get substantial help from the ICC or from some other source - and other funding sources are few and far between.

So why exactly did you abandon India? To get what from the ICC? I told you they are not getting anything from the ICC.


4. Crucial to their quest to better financial health is income from the ICC, in the form of distribution and World Cup participation fees, which makes qualification for the 2019 event even more important.

I told you that without qualification they will only get that money if they qualify for the CWC. I also told you they’ve flushed money down the drain for an event that they 99% will not qualify for.


5. Zimbabwe has embarked on an ambitious project to convince certain players who had left the country to return, but the flipside of that has been the toll it has taken on their finances.

I told you that the money spent on these players will hurt the organisation badly. All of you forget things like the costs of insurance, fees of drafting such complicated and stupid contracts etc.


6. Both Brendan Taylor and Kyle Jarvis are being paid more than they were at Nottinghamshire and Lancashire respectively, and were also given a small portion as an advance to secure their return. Solomon Mire, based in Australia, received what one source said was a "good deal, better than that of the other players who have stayed behind".

I told you this was extremely bad busniness with the returns NEVER EVER going to justify the means. Precisely because ZC knew well in advance of doing this that Tests were no longer relevant. Wait till Jarvis players ODIs & T20s. Then he will really look like an absolute waste of money and a thoroughly stupid decision by extremely stupid and incompetent fools!!!


7. Unsurprisingly, the treatment of the trio has created issues within the team. "Players who come back automatically get paid more than the guys who are there," one source said. "It's bad because there are players who have made sacrifices to stay in Zimbabwe and they are suffering."

It’s pretty clear that these new players are not really worth that much more than the players who remained and time will back that up entirely. Let’s see how much better they will do against Afghanistan than those who remained.


8. … employee and player salaries … part-paid at the end of October because of the financial challenges their board faces

Again it was silly of you here to try and deflect this. You said it was ok, only Admin not getting paid. Then again argued that it was temporary and they were waiting for funds to filter through from the ICC so they could get paid in full. You were in denial about a totally obvious situation. For what?


9. Zimbabwe's players have yet to receive their match fees for the Sri Lanka tour that took place in July.

So playing away is cheaper, and that’s your strategy, but even after you’ve played away you still can’t play players. How will it work out better in future when all Tests are away? Match fees will get paid? In any event players were never going to get paid October salaries with match fees outstanding from July.


10. A proposed increase in player allowance for this season's domestic matches has also not come to pass.

They offered domestic players an increase despite knowing they won’t be able to afford it. Standard Pakistani behaviour. In any even if Aliseni thought it wasn’t worth it then even that increase was an insult.


11. At least one board member is understood to have opposed the efforts to lure Taylor, Jarvis and Mire back because of the expense

This man(men?) is the biggest hero of cricket in Zimbabwe. He single-handedly tried to avoid the death of cricket in Zimbabwe. A side already going to fall behind other Associates in ODIs, and already behind a number of them in T20s has killed the game in Zimbabwe without providing solutions to that situation.


12. the prospect of having them in the team for the World Cup qualifiers motivated ZC to do "everything it could", according to the source, to convince the players to commit to Zimbabwe.

All the more reason why mass resignation and civil suits should happen WHEN they fail to qualify, and ZC should abandon the contracts because they neglected to include the definite performance clause to justify the expense. Whatever you think of them, Bvute and Chingoka would never have been this stupid.


13. the limited opportunities to raise money that will not be easy.

Again gutter journalism, and still no mention of India. Income from India used to be able to help ZC host Tests plus pay huge chunks of the Loan to reduce interest. Financials will definitely show that this loan has actually skyrocketed like never before in just the short stint of this Pakistani. They will prove that he has allowed it to balloon.


14. ICC money will be an important source of income and rationalisation of costs will have to continue. With no Test ranking points for Zimbabwe to concern themselves with, there would appear to be sense in not hosting home Tests. So even though they will not abandon Tests altogether, this could lead to a fundamental shift in outlook and the way they position themselves as a cricketing nation.

I told you cricket in Zimbabwe was dead. . Why rationalise costs if you’re “loaded” after the new ICC bumper deal to reduce India's cut for your benefit? Why ditch the Tests you can now afford? Unless you were duped?


15. In that light, it is not outlandish to wonder whether West Indies might have been the last team that will play a Test in Zimbabwe for a while. According to the current FTP, Zimbabwe are scheduled to host Pakistan for a two-Test series next year in June-July, a tour which also includes three ODIs and two T20Is. Preceding that, Australia visit for a tour that was originally scheduled to include two Tests, but no longer does; instead they will feature in a T20I tri-series alongside Pakistan

.So these guys are smarter than the old management hey. They found a way to avoid substituting Tests for LOIs?


16. The Logan Cup, Zimbabwe's first-class competition, for example, may be shortened from its current format - in which teams play each other in a double round - to a single round, and there could be an increase in domestic ODI and T20 competitions.

Indeed, cricket in Zimbabwe is well and truly dead!

---

The one thing that I never expected was for forumites to go on the defensive and be in denial. Right in front of your eyes, in broad daylight, decisions were made to literally kill cricket in Zimbabwe, and the one place that you would expect to swiftly pick this up and start online petitions to block certain decisions and demand the dismissal of certain people actually gave praises instead. Mind boggling! I read somewhere that ZCF will be celebrating 10 years, and the sentiments as all of this was unfolding were extremely disappointing.

Years from now you will read this forum online and ask yourselves, how on earth did we miss this. This forum was supposed to be the catalyst to prevent such from happening, open people's eyes. To read people trying to shift blame to the past and years of mismanagement only serves to make things worse. Potentially you could be starring at a well thought out and well planned strategy to kill of Zimbabwe cricket, with some people complicit but you're shifting blame. This was not an organic death. This was murder of the highest degree. Malicious, willful and premeditated. But it was also a perfect murder because "ZC did everything it could" to avoid the death of cricket in Zimbabwe. Even better, they fed the "Rising Stars" an overdose of One Day cricket only! A precursor for their future!

This is all going to get even nastier and uglier. The journalists are still avoiding the ICC deal regarding the support towards the loan, the loan still standing and its status, plus India (BCCI). It will get even worse because of player discontent.

Whether you like it or not cricket in Zimbabwe is very dead now. More than it has ever been. Another point that you denied when I said it because at least back then ZC took the step of its own volition because ICC had no legal basis to force them to do so, plus ZIM knew they were still in control and could get back whenever they set their minds to it.

ZIM is not marketable. So revenue will actually decrease not increase - be it sponsorship or TV Rights deals. Their LOI results won't get any better. They stand a greater chance of dropping further down the rankings than rising.

In an nutshell, they are doomed, and I can assure you when the figures are finally released, what Firdose Moonda reported as "a small portion as an advance to secure their return" will actually turn out to not be so small because Brendan and Kyle would not have been so stupid to return if all of this was fully disclosed to them which it wasn't plus ZC had no legal obligation to, and the amount of money they received in advance actually means it's substantial enough for them to be too indebted to ZC so much that they won't be able to challenge or leave without having to face the prospect of buying themselves out of the contracts.

Most of you will try to discredit what I'm saying and deflect again refusing to appreciate the total uniqueness of this situation. However, like Liam, Tristan and Firdose, they too will inevitably be forced to gradually reveal the truth. They are so far out of their depth as far as this is concerned that they are literally being forced to put their names against every embarrassing " exposé "! So it'll be easy for you to do so from the comfort of the forum, but for them, they will have to endure the discomfort professionally.
ZCF Hall of Famer
Reason on these four points for the rest of the year over and over again.

1. Faisal Hasnain left his job as International Cricket Council chief financial officer.

2. ZC Appointed Feroza Shariff new head of finance. Rhodes University-trained Shariff. She has previously worked for FBC Bank and auditing firm KPMG.

3. You have a highly trained banker-auditor on the one hand, and a Chief Financial Officer of the world's cricket body who left a cushy job. Both unconsciously came to receive part salary payment at collapsing ZC? :?

4. Combination: KPMG and Pakistani.

Just a reminder....


Haisnan and Shariff’s appointments, sources say, are part of efforts by the ZC board to tighten screws on funds and convince the international cricket community that there is genuine turnaround taking place in the Zimbabwe game.

There is talk that the ICC might soon bail out ZC to salvage a game that has teetered on the brink of collapse in recent times.

The ICC were convinced by the way, and they bailed out ZC to salvage cricket in Zimbabwe.

Anyway, what do I know. I'm just an idiot and a troll. ;)
ZCF Hall of Famer
Pariah, you have offered no alternative other than playing India C every three months. India has little interest in touring Zimbabwe now that they don't need our vote for anything. You stayed silent through any number of mismanaged disasters at ZC yet choose now to speak out about the dire financial situation. You really can't handle the fact that a Pakistani is in-charge. You praise those who blew the money, yet criticize the ones actually trying to clean-up the mess.
ZCF Hall of Famer

So why exactly did you abandon India? To get what from the ICC? I told you they are not getting anything from the ICC.


India is not going to save ZC. India has been touring regularly with their A team since 2010...what good did that do? Indigenous Zimbos stole all the money. Even if ZC gets a trillion USD, they will be broke the very next day when Embezzlememt Mukubanga and Larceny Kachachinga make deposits of 500 billion each to Metbank accounts. Then spokesman, Bankrupt Abrakadabra, will claim the money just "disappeared" when it was really moved at the behest of Selfishness Chikudinga.


All of you forget things like the costs of insurance, fees of drafting such complicated and stupid contracts etc.


Costs the same to insure 2 extra guys as it does 15 others. Drafting fees would be what $100 per contract? Doesnt scratch the surface on 10 million dollars a month bailouts.


It’s pretty clear that these new players are not really worth that much more than the players who remained and time will back that up entirely. Let’s see how much better they will do against Afghanistan than those who remained.


If you mean useless players like Vusi, then Taylor and Jarvis are both averaging more than 7 batting in non-opening positions, which is what Vusi averages.

A team with Vusi, Elton, and Prosper wouldn't even be able to compete with Scotland, forget about Afghanistan.


Whatever you think of them, Bvute and Chingoka would never have been this stupid.


Whomsaid they were stupid? They are greedy and thieving. Different words.


Indeed, cricket in Zimbabwe is well and truly dead!


Your ideological comrades killled it.
ZCF Hall of Famer
One of the ICC votes was 9-1...meaning even if the ZC voted with India, it wasnt going to change things.

Also in 2014, the ZC did side with India and was willing to give its Test status up. The BCB cut a deal with India so that BD and ZIM could keep playing tests (our public wouldnt have accepted otherwise).
ZCF Hall of Famer
Pariah this isn’t really a revelation that there is still Deep money issues. Did anyone ever disagree with you? I didn’t.

Rising stars is also a divided issue. I’ve sided with you to an extent there. So did googly, and a few others. Some disagree with us and their reasoning is also solid. It’s ideology.

What we were championing was the effort to insulate the ground troops from the money issues so we don’t lose players. KEY. And to entice expats to return. KEY.

The Pakistani isn’t perfect but he’s trying and time will tell of his success.

What I personally have a concern with as the others have said is you have repeatedly talked up and spruiked the thieves. You’ve praised Bvute, Chingoka while they sent us into the abyss. You justified it as it was happening.

Now you are criticising people trying to get us out of it, and without realising it by acknowledging the severe theft that you were wrong to be their PR arm on the ZCF forum. Some are reading it as hypocrisy, others are reading it as you don’t care as long as the people doing it were black.

For every negro turning a blind eye to other negros taking advantage and stealing from their own, they make it harder for the good negro who is trying to help his people in a genuine way. That’s what the lefties do when they turn a blind eye to mistreatment of women in Arab countries. You make it so much harder for the good honest people who want to change things from within for the better.
ZCF Hall of Famer

That’s what the lefties do when they turn a blind eye to mistreatment of women in Arab countries.


Apart from the use of the n word to describe pariah's comrades, this statement is deeply flawed in the sense that the western neocon doesn't have the moral authority to criticize Moozlums for abusing women a little too much.

No Arab head of state has as of yet, bragged about grabbing pussies and getting away with it due to their oil money. Patriarchy and mysogyny arent exclusive to Arabs...its exclusive to people who have d**ks between their legs. This is a human problem. Anyone who thinks othewise is not interested in women's rights as much as they are dissing foreigners.
ZCF Hall of Famer
Lefties are indeed, very painful to be around.
ZCF Hall of Famer

Kriterion_BD wrote: ↑Sun Nov 05, 2017 3:40 am


That’s what the lefties do when they turn a blind eye to mistreatment of women in Arab countries.


No Arab head of state has as of yet, bragged about grabbing pussies and getting away with it due to their oil money. Patriarchy and mysogyny arent exclusive to Arabs...its exclusive to people who have d**ks between their legs. This is a human problem. Anyone who thinks othewise is not interested in women's rights as much as they are dissing foreigners.


1- there is no way grabbing a p***y and gloating is anywhere NEAR as bad as throwing rocks at a girl until her skull is broken and she dies.

2- you’ve sort of done exactly what I described, you’ve equated two issues that aren’t equitable, played one down, Showing my point that that kind of mindset has made it hard for Muslims who want to change this kind of thing to make progress because smarter Muslims like yourself won’t tackle the issue head on, would rather skirt the issues than face them.

3- yes I love dissing foreigners and this thread starting to go off track now!
ZCF Hall of Famer
Taylor and Jarvis getting money in advance was definitely a move that raised eyebrows. A lot of people were not happy about that so I heard and people really must have been naive to think those guys sacrificed anything to come back when they were given multi year contracts and paid an advance worth more than they were currently getting.

In the end Taylor and Jarvis have to perform otherwise there will be a revolt. That just the truth. They were given special treatment so they have to perform. We can't start giving excuses about them not being that good etc..

If we don't qualify for the world cup we will be in serious trouble. All the players know they are playing for their future so they bettter turn up.

I would also like to point out that it's not only black people who financially manipulate the system. Alistair Campbell is a very shady character for example.. I'm sure if you audit the Pakistan tour you will find out what I mean. Suddenly his company was sponsoring the team but did they really pay the amount required to sponsor the team? so let's not put people in categories
ZCF Hall of Famer

ZIMDOGGY wrote: ↑Sun Nov 05, 2017 7:19 am

1- there is no way grabbing a p***y and gloating is anywhere NEAR as bad as throwing rocks at a girl until her skull is broken and she dies.


I didn't say it was. Perhaps my English is not as good as yours, but what I said was p***y grabbers simply lack the authority to brag about how well they treat humans with pussies vis a vis the rock throwers. I am asking for enough honesty for the conservative to not pretend that they give a s**t about a woman who is not their immediate relative. I understand they wouldn't kill a girl...great, but why expect a medal just for that?

How do people know its fake concern for women? Why prevent women from accessing reproductive healthcare? Oral contraceptives have many medical indications from polycystic ovarian syndrome to dysmenorrhea (google it) and many other conditions. Its not just about murdering fetuses.

I'll give you another example.

Just this week I watched Sean Hannity talk about countries where gays were being thrown off buildings. Thats a fine point if you believe gays have the right to marry and if transgender people can use whichever bathroom they choose, and if you think the military shouldn't spend 1 million dollars on gender reassignment surgery but its OK to spend on 40 million for viagra for straight men.


2- you’ve sort of done exactly what I described, you’ve equated two issues that aren’t equitable, played one down, Showing my point that that kind of mindset has made it hard for Muslims who want to change this kind of thing to make progress because smarter Muslims like yourself won’t tackle the issue head on, would rather skirt the issues than face them.


Those who truly wish to aid the "smarter muslims", heres how to do it, and its up to them if they want to heed my advice or not.

Please do not demonize them for "not standing up" when muslims like the Peshmerga are on the front lines battling jihadists. Please do not support those politicians, organizations, ideologies, or movements that engage in demonization of these "smarter muslims" like Geert van Wilders, Marine Le Pen, and others. Anyone unable or unwilling to do this - its easy no action is needed - they cannot help, nor should their services be sought.

Demonization of the other - black, gay, or muslim - is the way of the feeble-minded.
ZCF Hall of Famer
Just a couple of things before this thread gets locked out. The original post (and poster) probably deserved this derailment given how the other threads get derailed because of him :)

You can continue to talk about this article on this thread which was already present: http://www.zimcricketforums.com/viewtop ... =3&t=14248

And one has to commend the extent to which derailments are allowed these days here, given this was how a thread was closed down in the initial days of ZCF: Blast from the past: Possibly the first locked thread on ZCF: http://www.zimcricketforums.com/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=33

:D
ZCF Hall of Famer
Pariah you spent years arguing for and now you are vociferously against?

Anyone arguing against Jarvis’ and Taylor’s return don’t really understand cricket.

Anyone claiming their pay packages have strained the coffers hasn’t done the numbers, and choose to ignore where the bulk of the cash has really gone. It’s a great side show to distract everyone from the real issues and culprits.

If there’s an issue amongst the other players about those two getting more and that there should be some sort of equality then I’m afraid they don’t understand anything.

A downing of tools to protest this when a blind eye is turned about every other issue will prove with some finality what dumb manipulated sheep our players are. If that ever happens then I will walk away.

I’m curious why ZC can’t renege on this mystery 18m outstanding loan under our new leader?
ZCF Hall of Famer
Air Zimbabwe will become Zimbabwe Airways, why can’t ZC become ZCB and we walk from our “commitments” to our bosses private bank? 😂
ZCF Hall of Famer

Googly wrote: ↑Sun Nov 05, 2017 12:00 pm

Pariah you spent years arguing for and now you are vociferously against?

Anyone arguing against Jarvis’ and Taylor’s return don’t really understand cricket.

Anyone claiming their pay packages have strained the coffers hasn’t done the numbers, and choose to ignore where the bulk of the cash has really gone. It’s a great side show to distract everyone from the real issues and culprits.

If there’s an issue amongst the other players about those two getting more and that there should be some sort of equality then I’m afraid they don’t understand anything.

A downing of tools to protest this when a blind eye is turned about every other issue will prove with some finality what dumb manipulated sheep our players are. If that ever happens then I will walk away.

I’m curious why ZC can’t renege on this mystery 18m outstanding loan under our new leader?


We know Hami's contract is worth ~ 65,000 USD a year (recent article from Mohammad Isam highkighting that ZIM and IRE players earn more than Bangladeshi players).

Assuming Taylor and Jarvis signed 4 year deals worth 1 million USD each, means 250,000 per year. Sounds like a lot, but pales in comparison to the hundreds of millions the ZC has gotten from the ICC from World Cups, grants, bailouts, etc.

So of hhm wants to cry about 250k...he is a hyocrite or he's psychotic.
ZCF Hall of Famer
I give up with you guys. I was going to post articles that prove that even the old white led crciket board (ZImbabwe Cricket Union) which only served just a tiny a fraction of the people in ZIM, also had troubles. That Admin too were paid more than the players. And they had fights with the players as a result.

Also part of the reason why some players left Zimbabwe cricket. But why bother? I've posted them before plenty times and it was deflected and defended.

You just don't see it!
ZCF Hall of Famer

pariah wrote: ↑Sun Nov 05, 2017 8:49 pm

I give up with you guys. I was going to post articles that prove that even the old white led crciket board (ZImbabwe Cricket Union) which only served just a tiny a fraction of the people in ZIM, also had troubles. That Admin too were paid more than the players. And they had fights with the players as a result.

Also part of the reason why some players left Zimbabwe cricket. But why bother? I've posted them before plenty times and it was deflected and defended.

You just don't see it!


Doesnt matter if the whites stole 100 million. The blacks stole 200. Your denial wont change it.

I really wonder what your bank statements look like, pariah, as vociferously as you defend the indefensible theft by indigenous ZIM admins of ZC.
ZCF Hall of Famer

Kriterion_BD wrote: ↑Sun Nov 05, 2017 8:54 pm
Doesnt matter if the whites stole 100 million.[/quoteHow many of them doing the stealing, and from how many victims?


The blacks stole 200.

How many of them doing the stealing, and from how many victims?
ZCF Hall of Famer

pariah wrote: ↑Sun Nov 05, 2017 8:49 pm

I give up with you guys. I was going to post articles that prove that even the old white led crciket board (ZImbabwe Cricket Union) which only served just a tiny a fraction of the people in ZIM, also had troubles. That Admin too were paid more than the players. And they had fights with the players as a result.

Also part of the reason why some players left Zimbabwe cricket. But why bother? I've posted them before plenty times and it was deflected and defended.

You just don't see it!


There have always been player/admin battles in ZCU/ZC. The difference being in the 90s the battles were over how to best run cricket, whereas in the 2000s the battles have been over how best to steal money and keep the players obedient.
ZCF Hall of Famer

Kriterion_BD wrote: ↑Sun Nov 05, 2017 8:54 pm
..the indefensible theft by indigenous ZIM admins of ZC.

None of you and all journos globally have ever proved this.

My version remains fact, and yours fiction.

I had interesting discussions on this in Conant's article a 4 years ago

http://www.theroar.com.au/2013/09/29/wh ... /#comments

Where is betterdays?


Wonderful article and very interesting Conant! But of course Peter Ndlovu is better than George Shaya lol! None of our cricket teams(Flower era included) have ever had the kind of overall talent Zimbabwe’s national football teams have had – particularly the two generations stretching from 1990-2006. After all, it’s not that hard to look good, or come close to achieving something as a nation in a sport that only comprises 10 nations at most. Like Cricket, a similar situation exists in Rugby. Football operates at a much higher level. Australia merely reaching the 2006 round of 16 in the FIFA World Cup ranks greater than any RWC, CWC or Ashes & Tri-Nations victory they’ve ever achieved!

Back to the gist of your article, it’s such a pity that our boys won’t be playing another Test so soon after a well-deserved triumph. I fancied our chances against Sri Lanka. Right now our boys are a highly talented bunch and the support players are of top quality too. Cricket in Zimbabwe has never at any point been blessed with such depth in riches, and most importantly, the key performers are the very products of the policies reviled by many ignorant people divorced from true happenings on the ground, but just a well thought out cumulative media demonization campaign over the years to speak from.

In your own uncharacteristic contradiction, you unconsciously reveal a lot of valuable information. We find the answers as to why this tour is not happening, and for the right reasons. You accurately commend and highlight how this new administration has been bold in making the right decisions, where previously that was expected though not the case – which in itself shows that the Mukondiwa led administration is actually competent & bold. That Bvute the esteemed predecessor similarly made tough decisions and was a highly respected administrator is common knowledge, so it follows that this new administration is neither a lowering of standards, nor his absence a damaging loss. Consequently your criticism should be pointed at some of the rot that was sown in the time between those two administrations.

Some of the ICC imposed suggestions forced compromises which, within a short period of time, significantly burdened Zimbabwe Cricket for years to come. If you recall, several faces including Alistair Campbell, Neil Manthorp etc, plus some substandard pensioner cricketers and fringe county players were brought in to give an impression to some narrow minded people that all was well. You see, the mere presence of our fairer cousins is all the evidence that’s needed to prove that something in Africa actually functions. The late Peter Roebuck highlighted these things. Just like IMF-WB and its ESAP on Zimbabwe’s economy, these left ZC with millions in debt. Where are these self-less cricketers now that ZC is no longer willing to borrow further to overpay them as part of a cosmetic exercise, at the expense of its children(local players, coaches and administrators)? They are playing cricket, coaching and commentating all over the world after making a quick buck and gaining scarce mandatory experience for better paying jobs there, while regularly taking time off to utter negatives about Zimbabwe and Zimbabwe cricket in the social media circles – the very nation they owe so much to!

Some may argue their experience was required, but Zimbabwe had a functioning FC system before it was suspended due to lack of funds in 2006, and was resumed in 2007. True they had administrative challenges along the way, but Chatara aside, virtually all the players responsible for our recent victories were developed before the costly compromises were implemented, not after! Even the likes of Hamilton Masakadza, Prosper Utseya & Elton Chigumbura among many others, (along with the absent Taibu & Matsikenyeri etc) were products of the Peter Chingoka led administration’s tireless efforts, foresight and scholarships. The only thing those needlessly costly changes did was earn acceptance. Had crucially needed funds been made available in 2005, our boys would have been much further today, plus resumed Test cricket much earlier than 2011.

Going back to your contradiction I allude to, these Conant are the reasons why ZC could not afford host another Sri Lanka tour – opportunity cost! The domestic FC season which was in danger of not happening will actually begin soon. A large number of developing players were enrolled to a resuscitated academy where they’ve been receiving quality cricket training during our off-season. Other top non-contracted reserve players, who take our national players core up to 25 players, have been in camp as “sparring partners” to our first XI during incoming tours, which is why the heroics of the brilliant Tinashe Panyangara could be readily called upon. As we speak, our u19s(just like our national u15&17s months before in South Africa) are getting a hammering in India, but a necessary education nonetheless. Several support staff such as the grounds men who pulled off a miracle to produce a magnificent pitch within such a short turnaround time – something highly paid ground staff in top cricket nations fail to achieve with months of paid advance notice&preparation – are being meagrely remunerated but a wage even so. ZC admin staff had to selflessly forgo their salaries so that the overdue salaries of our justifiably impatient players could be honoured.

Their TV income amounts to peanuts, there is no significant domestic or foreign sponsorship coming in, and the public cannot afford to pay hefty gate charges. Where is the revenue coming from? They have to resort to borrowing to supplement this, considering the very sum of the money they receive from the ICC at intervals is completely dwarfed by what they have had to borrow over the same time for their unavoidable budgetary needs. They had already hosted enough over the last couple of years and cannot afford much else(AUS XI twice, SA XI twice, BD XI once, BD twice, NZ once, IND once & PAK twice). In between they’ve toured NZ&WI once each which was a loss because they could not afford the flights to begin with, and barely managed a surplus from the little they got out of their brief appearance at the T20 WC. Therefore, the little left from India’s tour (the only profit-making tour all these years) after servicing some of the outstanding debts, a nation’s entire domestic season’s demands could not be overlooked to fulfil a single loss-making tour! All the more reason why they are pushing for a Tri-Series involving Aus&SA next year, so hopefully that income, including a little from the WC that year can sustain them going forward, seeing as the FTP reveals a bleak calendar and revenue for years to come.

Comparatively, if India doesn’t tour South Africa this year (or a long tour), it will have huge ramifications for the game in the country, stretching over many years. School, junior, club, provincial, franchise and national cricket will be affected – players, coaches, academies and admin staff will all be affected. Facing reduced revenue, in the long term, some jobs will be cut, salaries will be reduced and there will be player plus staff walkouts and ultimately a weak cricket team. Not as much affected as Zimbabwe, but sufficient to dent the nation’s cricket and be blamed on the ANC!

Not wanting to be dictated to, years ago ZC adopted much needed policies which some cricket countries didn’t like (by extension the country as a whole), so they voted with their feet and Aus&Eng money was followed them. Similarly CSA’s decision – not that I rate Lorgat or his appointment but they are entitled to it – has brought this dilemma to them as well. That’s not corruption, that’s loss of revenue beyond their control depending on the way you look at it. In Zimbabwe’s case, if even weakened international Aus, Eng&SA sides, like India recently, had also toured, instead of merely burdening them with costs through their A side like Aus&SA did, Zimbabwe would not be in so much debt or be cancelling SL right now! Period!

You, along with some here, accuse ZC of being corrupt&incompetent, something that I and indeed many other fair&unbiased observers deny. All this while, their relatively clean audited financials have been available for scrutiny by all stakeholders or concerned parties. As with all other Full Members & Associates, the ICC has been able to study things for themselves several times before. They have not reported anything on the contrary or found anything that is highly uncommon in the administrative lives of all others including CSA, ECB, CA etc. While some form of corruption and mismanagement of funds by Black ZC administrators isn’t non-existent, the extent to which it has been portrayed or its effects is a myth, and I could’ve used stronger words than that. So until the day all you naysayers can provide tangible, irrefutable proof of the level os corruption&mismanagement alluded to, I suggest you limit your comments to commendation of ZC administrators and the loyal remaining players for their discernible efforts. Nothing more! They immensely warrant our unreserved respect.



If you want any information on Zimbabwe cricket(financials, audit and corporate governance reports etc), feel free to contact ZC. Even the ICC will gladly disclose to you all the latest information they have which should be as up to date as mid 2012. Or better yet, why don’t you ask the ECB&CA for what information they have and share with us their response then we can talk. There were specific prerequisites to Zimbabwe Cricket being recently granted US$1.5mil over 3 years, of the TAPP fund by the ICC EXECUTIVE BOARD, and if they didn’t meet them they wouldn’t have received the money (http://www.espncricinfo.com/ci-icc/cont ... 86476.html). Mugabe’s mere existence, and Cameron for that matter, or the nature of the relationship of the ZC President with him, as with ECB Chairperson & the Prime Minister, does not miraculously redefine the accuracy of those facts or the universally accepted standards by which they are measured.

So what if Peter Chingoka is close to his Excellency President Mugabe – which is far from being the case though, but naturally you’ve been conveniently educated otherwise by the shamelessly selective media! He’s probably had fewer meetings with Mugabe than your Queen herself has probably had with him over the years! Being banned or on travel lists(i.e. random bullying) by hypocritical figures & authorities with vastly superior gross human rights backgrounds, simply because economically they are in an advantageous and influential position to do so, hardly makes those judgements morally worth any more than the paper their printed on now does it. Last time I checked, the US is not part of that joke called the ICC(Hague). Neither are our fellow cricket Full Member countries India&Pakistan. If it had any semblance of relevance then I doubt if the White House&Downing Street would have ever had a single resident who lasted beyond half of their first single full term! Like you and I Mugabe will eventually die, only far more revered & immortalised globally than either of us, plus nearly all the leaders you respect. However, there’s absolutely no reason for him to be at the Hague at all, or be concerned about its existence. None whatsoever. Those are the facts my friend!



Ireland will never be a Full Member at Zimbabwe’s expense. In fact, Ireland(or Canada) will never be made a Full Member alone. Either Afghanistan (or one of Kenya/Namibia/UAE) will be simultaneously voted in alongside them or before they are. Truth be told, all countries & boards, including the ECB&CA, are in some form puppets of the BCCI – far more than Zimbabwe is. You’d be lying to yourself if you convinced yourself otherwise.

I know my story! ;)


The onus on investing time in obtaining them and presenting those figures rests with the accuser. Why waste time and money to build up a defence to silly accusations which at their core lack substance?! There are many avenues beside ZC, through whom you can corroborate provided information or obtain suppressed facts.

Apart from ZC’s HR office, ZIMRA(Inland Revenue Service) has all the salary information for the individuals you point to. If you follow the relevant internal or legal channels they will present you with those facts – even if it’s delayed or not in electronic format lol! But ultimately you’ll get it. Zimbabwe is not a failed state, neither are its people and its systems dysfunctional. They function and you can safely navigate them if you so wish.

Similarly the Franchise system ensured that all foreign FC&List A players were employed by CEOs who run the franchises and contract the players independently of ZC, whose commitment was an agreed grant. Of all CEOs, Stanley Staddon & Kenyon Ziehl were the biggest culprits in terms of taking more than the necessary advantage of that system, so you can contact the Rhinos&Tuskers offices for those salary disclosures of the needless imports. All the more reason why rounds of the 4 day Logan Cup matches had to be cut to accommodate salaries for the ZC run T20, within that grant, after the Dominus T20 failed under the leadership of the contracted firm.

Yes coming to that Stanbic Bank T20, Dominus the baby of the sly combination of Alistair Campbell & Dirk Viljoen was responsible for paying the players and admin staff associated with it. ZC’s crime was to contribute/invest a sum of money plus Zimbabwean players largely paid by ZC, while they had no direct&legal hands-on oversight of the venture, and ultimately got nothing in return pretty much writing that off as development costs. Those two figures, together with their associates, are the people whom we should be asking questions as to how much they received in TV rights from Naspers owned DSTV Supersport, and how they spent it. ZC financials give us some insight, what of Dominus?

One guy here refers to that well publicised yet unknown KPMG report which never left the room. Perhaps the US(CIA),UK&EU, and indeed Mugabe’s government itself judging by some cables, need to enlist the services of whoever ZC&KPMG is making use of because not a single person was able to leak this so called damaging report! ChrisUK needs to apply common sense here. We’re in the 21st century. Surely for Malcolm to speak in authority about this report – lest he be written off as a terminal and pathetic liar, he and indeed other executives, had to have had a copy and examined it personally. Unless of course he was only allowed that privilege under armed guard or some other form duress. Following which that part of his memory was erased to the point where he could not disclose a single note with figures to back it up. In any case Speed himself said “there was no compelling evidence of personal gain” in the report (which means you can all keep quiet about Bvute-Chingoka dipping their hands). Anyway, it’s similar to the BCCI’s concerns about Lorgat whom they wanted referred to the ICC’s Ethics committee but that was ignored.

Going back to the admin salaries, it doesn’t matter how much ALL the admin staff have earned in comparison to the sacrifice they had to make, it remains contractually what they were entitled to and for the majority it’s nothing significant. They like all the players have always received a retainer due to them, only the match fees and other earnings apart from the basic was outstanding for the cricketers. I doubt many of the admin staff are entitled to more than their basic. Of course as you say I should quote figures to my knowledge, which I would gladly do to follow ZC’s lead. They have not felt compelled to reveal more information than is a basic requirement or voluntary example set by any other board, so why should they be selectively pushed to disclose information that others are not subjected to? While ZC&CSA are officially the only boards running at a loss, technically only the BCCI is liquid and running at a profit, and the rest are in the red. In fact, some like the BCB, WICB, SLCB etc have had major financial troubles involving player salaries. Ironically, questions asked of Zimbabwe have never been asked of them on a similar scale by the scathing media. Until then the advantage rests with the INNOCENT & FALSELY accused ZC.

NB: Judging by you reference to the ZCF, it means that squad’s exclusive domain is still up! Lol!! Once Loki freezes the gatekeeper, get Scotty to beam me up, but I won’t hold my breath! Meanwhile no worm is nibbling into my gourd plant so I’ll be basking under my shade. On the contrary, the wilderness is kinder than I thought …just tell me who Anti that putrid surgical tail is…



“”Tbh, I am not interested in ECB or CSA’s financial issues but as an avid follower of Zim cricket and having emotionally invested in the team I would like – regardless of legalities – for them to be clear…..I am not asking ZC to answer to external bodies [but to] those with a positively passionate interest. I don’t judge by comparison; I believe, to move forward, we, as Zimbabweans, must be self-critical (of course, we defend each other too … but I cannot – by labelling it ‘fighting hypocrisy’ – dismiss our faults by highlighting the faults in others).””

These are very sound positions that you’ve taken betterdays, and you qualify them very well. Unfortunately, while you may not judge by comparison, taking it into consideration will show you why information will never be at your fingertips where anything in Zimbabwe is concerned.

What I do know is that a lot of the financial information particularly pertaining to administrators, employees and sportspeople globally, is often the result of media speculation, not specifics, except for those who leaked those payslips and are still pursued by the law to this day. To expect Zimbabwe, ZC or any other institution to be religious where transparency is concerned is wishful.

While every other country freely and comfortably visits Zimbabwe for sports purposes, some(England of course) opt to sulk, politicise the matter, and do everything in their power to ostracise them internationally. Not to mention that they were solely opposed to Zimbabwe achieving Test status in the first place. From cricket their position has spread to every other sporting discipline. All founded on falsehoods, and of course ungrateful contemptible ambassadors such as Henry and Andy plus many others who were meant to be so called self-critical proponents. There are greater things at play which they nurse via how they manage information.

What I can state confidently is that Zimbabweans experience far more freedom and transparency in comparison to citizens of that Anglo-American axis. That is my opinion, but if you dig deeper you will unerringly arrive at the same conclusion.

You should be concerning yourself as to why Cricinfo etc always quote the likes of Taylor, Jarvis, Sean, Heath, Grant, Gillespie, Coltart etc, as opposed to the likes of Elton, Hondo, Chawaguta, Makoni, Tikolo, Chirombe or even Peter Chingoka himself when considering sensitive subjects. Or declare if and reasons given if their efforts to solicit interviews were rebuffed. At the end of the day the issues which tickle your curiosity stem from such reports, whose sources are strangely one dimensional. Inevitably then, you may find that you get worked up based on one side of the story which has been proven over 95% of the time to be false. Ever wondered that maybe you have very little or nothing to be overly worried about?!

Reply

Login to reply.