Skip to main content
ZCF

Home of cricket conversation, community and memory

Discussion

[Match Thread] 1st 'A' Test (Zimbabwe v New Zealand)

Zimbabwe Cricket Forum 25 posts 104 views

Discussion

ZCF Hall of Famer

Opening post


eugene wrote:I would select most people ahead of Dabengwa, maybe even Matsi.


Now you've lost the plot MAKING SUCH OUTLANDISH CLAIMS.

You need meds.
should be

1.S.Marillier

2.V.Sibanda

3.S.Williams

4.C.Ervine

5.F.Mutizwa

6.M.Waller

7.R.Chakabva

8.K.Meth

9.T.Panyangara

10.N.Mushangwe

11.T.Chetara
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer

andybligz wrote:should be

1.S.Marillier

2.V.Sibanda

3.S.Williams

4.C.Ervine

5.F.Mutizwa

6.M.Waller

7.R.Chakabva

8.K.Meth

9.T.Panyangara

10.N.Mushangwe

11.T.Chetara


That's exactly what my team would be. Will be interesting to see how Tinasche Panyangara goes about his business
ZCF Hall of Famer
Zimbabwe win toss and will field.
ZCF Hall of Famer
Zim Team: Marillier, Mawoyo, Masvaure, Sibanda, Ervine, Waller, Chakabva, Maruma, Mushangwe, Panyangara, Ncube.

NZ Team: McIntosh, Ingram, How, Flynn, Franklin, Hopkins, Young, Patel, Aldridge, Beard, Martin.
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer
What does Meth need to do to get a game ?? :x

And no Sean Williams ?!
Veteran
Two wickets for Panyangara already . Looks good lets keep the momentum going boys .
True 51/2, Panyangara doing the damage, Masvaure economy of 7.41 an over. There is no balance in this team, a lack of pace bowlers, should have included Meth to help out Panyangara and Ncube. Surprise Williams is not in, thought he would play first match then go to SA after for the ODI. These are the matches where our pace bowlers should be given a chance to improve,
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer
Ya i agree with you there. Keegan Meth should have been in the side, as should Tendai Chitara
Veteran
I Think Chitara should have been in, I see Vusi has already put himself on to bowl...

I thought let me see NZ collective test experience against ours. I stopped after the first bowler and Batsman. Their stats collectively over shadowed ours. Only three players without Test experience.

NZ

How - Batting - 19 Matches - 772 Runs

Chis Martin - Bowling - 56 Matches - 181 Wikckets

Zimbabwe

Vusi - Batting - 3 Matches - 48 Runs

Tinashe Bowling - 3 Matches - 8 Wikckets - (128 runs - Has more runs than Vusi in with HS of 40*)
Veteran

sloandog wrote:

andybligz wrote:should be

1.S.Marillier

2.V.Sibanda

3.S.Williams

4.C.Ervine

5.F.Mutizwa

6.M.Waller

7.R.Chakabva

8.K.Meth

9.T.Panyangara

10.N.Mushangwe

11.T.Chetara


That's exactly what my team would be. Will be interesting to see how Tinasche Panyangara goes about his business


Two wickets already for Tinashe Pannyangara. After this its straight into the national team. THRILLED!!!
ZCF Hall of Famer
Current partnership 124 runs, 18.2 overs, RR: 6.76

Ouch. NZ A making Zim A look terrible. I'm not sure if it's bad bowling or good batting, but you'd have to consider bowling an ultra-defensive line with a defensive field set just to stop the bleeding - even for a few overs. Picking such an inexperienced bowling attack is starting to hurt now.

Not sure why Ncube hasn't been brought back, but credit to Panyangara - not getting much support from the other bowlers, he's playing the lone ranger at the moment...
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer
This New Zealand A side is a quality team which would compoare favourably with the senior Zimbabwe side. There are many players with extensive international experience such as Chris Martin, Jeetan Patel, James Franklin, and Jamie How. The Zimbabwean team is mostly a team of young inexperienced players. I think we just need to look for individual performances and not focus too much on the result.
My All-time Zimbabwe XI
Neil Johnson, Brendan Taylor, Murray Goodwin, Andy Flower (w), David Houghton, Sean Williams, Heath Streak (c), Andy Blignaut, Paul Strang, Eddo Brandes, Blessing Muzarabani

brmtaylor.com admin wrote:Current partnership 124 runs, 18.2 overs, RR: 6.76

Ouch. NZ A making Zim A look terrible. I'm not sure if it's bad bowling or good batting, but you'd have to consider bowling an ultra-defensive line with a defensive field set just to stop the bleeding - even for a few overs. Picking such an inexperienced bowling attack is starting to hurt now.

Not sure why Ncube hasn't been brought back, but credit to Panyangara - not getting much support from the other bowlers, he's playing the lone ranger at the moment...


Tea time on first day N Z 281 for 3 in 59overs.At this rate N Z will get close to 450 by close of play.Very weak bowling attack the same as in the franchise.
Legend
Overall not too bad a performance to be honest, especially considering that it was 250+ for 2 at one stage.

However, I think that there was some poor selection and captaincy. After Ncube and Panyangara had bowled excellent opening spells, keeping it tight, and picking up a couple of wickets, Jamie How and Daniel Flynn were faced with an attack of Masvaure (19 wickets in 23 fc matches @ 50) and Sibanda (18 wickets in 70 fc matches @ 57). Neither of these two would be regularly used as first change options by their franchises, and both have very ordinary career records with the ball. They are frankly not front line bowlers, and whilst Masvaure's mediums might be a useful option in one cricket, I doubt Sibanda's will ever be even that good... Secondly, on the captaincy, Sibanda kept this attack (to 2 new batsmen) as Masvaure bowled 5 for 30, and Sibanda himself 3 overs for 23. Surely it should have dawned on him that a lot of free runs were given away, and he should have gone to spin much earlier... That said, it was not his fault that the selectors provided him with only one frontline seamer...

Well batted Dan Flynn, I've watched him play test cricket, and he looked an organised player. But, his test strike rate is 40, so for him to have scored 160 at a run-a-ball, there must have been some pretty average stuff being sent down.
aaghavs Lineups back again.................

Twenty 20

G.Flower----can bowl left arm spin

H.Masakadza----can bowl tooo

B.Taylor

S.Williams----can ball handy spin

C.Coventry

K.Meth---ALLROUNDER

E.Chigumbura--ALLROUNDER

A.Blignaut---ALLROUNDER

G.Cremer--leg break

P.Utseya---off spin

R.Price--left arm

extra

E.Reinsford

ODI

G.Ballance

H.Masakaza

G.Flower

B.Taylor

S.Williams

T.Taibu

A.Blignaut

E.Chigumbura

R.PRice

G.Cremer

E.Reinsford

Extra

P.Utseya

TEST

G.Balance

H.Masakadza

S.Williams

G.Flower

B.Taylor

C.Ervine

T.Taibu

A.Blignaut

R.Price

G.Cremer

E.Reinsford

Extra

S.Marillier
aaghavs Lineups back again.................

Twenty 20

G.Flower----can bowl left arm spin

H.Masakadza----can bowl tooo

B.Taylor

S.Williams----can ball handy spin

C.Coventry

K.Meth---ALLROUNDER

E.Chigumbura--ALLROUNDER

A.Blignaut---ALLROUNDER

G.Cremer--leg break

P.Utseya---off spin

R.Price--left arm

extra

E.Reinsford

ODI

G.Ballance

H.Masakaza

G.Flower

B.Taylor

S.Williams

T.Taibu

A.Blignaut

E.Chigumbura

R.PRice

G.Cremer

E.Reinsford

Extra

P.Utseya

TEST

G.Balance

H.Masakadza

S.Williams

G.Flower

B.Taylor

C.Ervine

T.Taibu

A.Blignaut

R.Price

G.Cremer

E.Reinsford

Extra

S.Marillier

A TEST TEAM

T.Duffin

S.Marillier

C.Ervine(C)

G.Lamb

C.Chibhabha

F.Mutziwa(w)

P.Masuvre

K.Meth

T.Maruma

S.Masakadza

I.Nicholson
avoid follow on please!!!

clikcspeed wrote:avoid follow on please!!!


337/6

No follow on mate, Zim or Zim A, actually do well in the longer version, even if they do not get the 1st innings right, they always bat well overrally, what is letting them down is bowling. Dave Houghton was right about us getting back in tests, where will improve as both bowlers and batsman have time to settle and play their game. Ithink we will draw this match.
ZCF Hall of Famer
Zimbabwe A declared, trailing by 61! A fairly aggressive move which is nice to see, although I still think it will result in a draw. But with Chakabva not out on 103 nobody could have blamed Sibanda for letting the batsmen stay out there and make sure of it.

Unless I'm reading too much into it and the declaration was a directive from the team management to give the bowlers some more time in the middle :)

Reply

Login to reply.