Skip to main content
ZCF

Home of cricket conversation, community and memory

Discussion

Tino under fire

Zimbabwe Cricket Forum 8 posts 38 views

Discussion

ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer

Opening post


zimfan1 wrote:
By the way Gargamel, i think thats being harsh on Hammy, he has won many games for Zimbabwe and has given a hell of a lot back to Zimbabwe cricket in his career, surely a future national team coach one day??


Have to agree with gargs here. As an outsider I fail to see the big deal about Hammy. I'm not saying he's not a key player (Tamim is one of our top men, but a huge underachiever so far) but winning games by bossing Kenya and Bermuda should not be the standard. Guys like Taylor and Taibu have ripped teams like Australia and South Africa. Even Tino has batted out an entire day against the likes of Ajmal. What has Hammy done to warrant the title of "second best behind Taylor"? More to the point, why is Chigs not rated as highly? Its acceptable for a 21 year old be be pleased with a gritty 30 against SA at home, but not for 31 yo elder statemen.
Bangladesh cricket fanatic, observer of all others.
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer

gargamel wrote:Hamilton has failed to convert . He is true colossal local bully in the Franchise system but when i try bench mark him with peers such as Clarke,Bravo,Kholi Amla he will never come close. I agree that he has not played a lot of cricket as compared to his peers but i would expect him to do as well. I maybe too old school but the likes of Barry Richards and Graemen Pollock had limited careers but their international averages are mid 40 plus. Hamilto to be honest should have been our leading batsman but he has not lived up to the potential that he showed with the 100 against the Windies as a 19 year old. In a professional setup this lad would have been classified as seen and deemed not good enough to cope.


Hami should have delivered more. Perhaps wit a modicum of admin support he might have. He is clearly best after Taylor. Williams may surpass him, but the others are struggling to get close. Hami is expected to perform and disappoints when he doesn't, the others are not expected to perform and surprise when they occasionally do.
The Third Innings
ZCF OriginalZCF Hall of Famer
I have always referred to Hammy as Santa Claus as he is fat, wears red, and shows up once a year.
My All-time Zimbabwe XI
Neil Johnson, Brendan Taylor, Murray Goodwin, Andy Flower (w), David Houghton, Sean Williams, Heath Streak (c), Andy Blignaut, Paul Strang, Eddo Brandes, Blessing Muzarabani
Legend

gargamel wrote:Hamilton has failed to convert . He is true colossal local bully in the Franchise system but when i try bench mark him with peers such as Clarke,Bravo,Kholi Amla he will never come close.


I understand your frustration, gargamel, but by that standard you would struggle to find 11 players for an all-time Zimbabwe XI.
Legend
Fairly simple with regards to Hamilton... Is he a world class player? Obviously, clearly, blatantly not. By any standard you want, he doesn't come remotely near the best in the world. However! He is very clearly one of the best in Zim, and absolutely deserves to be one of the first names on the team sheet. At both international and domestic level he outperforms almost all the competition. He is one of Zim's best players, and will continue to be so for many years yet. Is he Michael Clarke though?? Don't be silly...
Veteran

jimmylesaint wrote:foreignfield wrote:


CrimsonAvenger wrote:I'm still disgusted with the choice of words. I mean, treat him like a fellow human being. How can this language and approach be acceptable in any profession?

jimmylesaint wrote:... but does he have to use such derogatory remarks and in public?

I agree 100%. Tough approach my a**. With every statement it becomes more obvious that this guy has absolutely no clues about man management. He should just go and set up his own facebook group "Zim Cricket Rants" and leave the players alone.

What ever good Steven does I doubt if that will change your thoughts about him, I think he is actually doing the correct thing Calling A SPADE A SPADE NO SACRED COWS .Mangongo is right Tino and Vusi are a huge disapointment


This comment of yours just displays how much drugs you are smoking- or perhaps you have never experienced a professional team or set up, or even played competitive sport????

He can call a spade a spade without publicly humiliating them- frankly if that was me at the end of a puerile little outburst from a grown(very large) man,,there'd be a lawsuit sitting at Stevens' doorstep. How dare he treat players like children, jeopardise their earning potential in the off season overseas and in Zim . Insinuating that Tino just got wankered in UK at club level, a level that would thrash any of our franchise/provinces. What's Mangongos excuse....??? Just got fat on Sadza when he should be working in the nets doing throw downs like Walter is capable of.

Some of you think this method is working---perhaps if the squad were 13yrs old.

Why do you think Zim A is getting thrashed...do you think they like working with a sudden change of coach and manager---because Steven had a hissy fit...really Steven may even be Bi-Polar or Schizophrenic the way he is carrying on.

NO SACRED COWS?????Are you on magic mushrooms???!!! Mangongo is the sacred cow.....as long as he tows the Mukondiwa line of course.

There will be a big player to coach rebellion. I've been in Harare for 2 weeks and heard the rumblings.

No this isn't a race issue, it's a man management issue. Probably never in the history of Zim Cricket has a coach come up with such pathetic public outburts- him and Givemore both seem to have their pants down measuring their c**ks.... who will win as now it is Takashinga vs Takashinga.


I find this response quite insulting there is no need to insult myself cause i have a different view point
Veteran
Let's get this in perspective Zimlover/Conant et al

I agree what SteveM says, some of our players are not up to scratch, i've said it myself in previous posts, hence i agree with you.

BUT(a big butt) i disagree with the public way he has assassinated them-NEVER in my professional sporting life have i come across such asinine, ill thought out comments from a National Coach.

SM can call a spade a spade in private, coach to player chats-that's how professionals do it. To infer i hate SM and no matter what he says or does, itake umbrage, is also insulting since i back SM in most decisions he makes- but i'm not a yes sir type of chap and when he(SM) or any other does or behaves in a way that is wrong ,i'll chirp.

For me there is no agree or disagree or have "a different opinion" on this issue- simply put behaviour like this from a National Coach(particular of a Test Nation that the world looks up to)is unacceptable and is wrong. Just as walking up to someone and sticking a knife in their eyeball is wrong- there is no right about it!!There is no "oh i have a different opinion"

This is not a difference of opinion, it's simply my opinion is right and yours wrong, and 99/100 people would agree with that. :D

Perhaps my "insults" were not taken with a dry cup of sand, tongue in cheek.

Perhaps it is my mistake in thinking that everyone on here are seasoned professionals and would automatically realise the faux pas SM has done by going public with such outrageous shenannigans.... clearly a few of you don't and haven't :o

Just too make you feel better i'm off to eat magic mushrooms,smoke crack cocaine and reach levels of madness never experienced.


May I politely point out, jimmylesaint, that the quote in bold is not by me, but a response to my (and your and Crimson's) post ;)

I know :P
Veteran
Moving on.

Hammy at present is not a world class player, but if he had the right management- say he was in a different country that provides resources for the players and not for the Board meetings :D

Then i am 100% certain Hammy could be a world class player- he has

1)the skill

2)the psych

the rest can be improved on.

That goes for a few other guys but the harsh reality is even better players have left and the ones coming through are rightly being pushed to UK,Oz,SA for bursaries and Moms and Dads are looking out for their kids' entire future, not just a flash in Zim Cricket where quite simply Nationalism/Patriotism doesn't put bread on the table.

It's not a quick fix and people with real desire and drive are needed to fix it.

Reply

Login to reply.